You Can't Miss What You Never Had

Aug 06, 2015

 

Even in business-to-business selling the ways costs are presented can lead smart owners to make bad decisions.

 

Being caught between two parties at work has been a real eye-opener on how people perceive and react to costs.

On one side is a long-standing client – a smart, likeable business owner that we have enjoyed working with for many years. They are in retail and, about a year ago, switched merchant services providers. A merchant services provider is what allows a merchant to process credit cards. In exchange for providing that service the merchant services provider keeps a percentage (anywhere between 2%-6%) of the total transaction and passes the rest along to the merchant.

Because these merchant services fees are on the gross (after sales tax) value even small differences in these rates can have a huge impact on profitability. Smart retailers should review their merchant services deals at least once a year.

Their old merchant services provider was expensive. They kept a relatively big chunk of the transaction value – about 5%. If for example the merchant did $10,000 in sales the merchant services provider kept about $500 and passed the other (approximately) $9,500 along to the merchant.

To save money our client switched to a new merchant services provider, a well-respected and highly ethical company that we have worked with for years and recommended highly.

This company uses a very different model. They work very hard to find the best possible merchant services deals for their clients, evaluating options from countless merchant services providers. All the money, less the transaction fees (about 2%) now flow to the merchant. The company then charges a recovery fee, a percentage of the money that they are saving the client. To provide full transparency they disclose these fees and bill them separately, they don't bury them in the processing fees.

So with the new company that same $10,000 in sales would see about $200 go to the merchant services provider they selected, and the remaining $9,800 being passed along to the merchant, who has now saved about $300.

The company then charges back about $100 for the savings that they have provided. The merchant has still saved about $200.

 

 

Old MSP

New MSP

Sales

$10,000

$10,000

Passed Through To Merchant

$9,500

$9,800

Recovery Fee

$0

$100

Total Retained By Merchant

$9,500

$9,700

Savings For Merchant

 

$200

 

The savings are absolutely real. While investigating this that was clear – the merchant was going to save a lot of money with the new company.

But they were also going to be seeing money coming out of their account for the recover fee, and getting bills and statements to remind them yet again, and they just couldn't get past that. No matter how much they were really saving all they could see was what it was costing.

 

You Can't Miss What You Never Saw

With the old merchant services provider the real cost was very abstract. Sales were rung in each day, and a couple of days later money showed up in there account. It was hard to compare it directly to sales because of cut-off times, but one thing was easy to understand: what they got, they kept. It didn't matter that they were getting less – they couldn't miss money that they never saw.

But, under the new deal, they bitterly resented the charges. Even though they were still saving a significant amount of money they were constantly being reminded of what it cost them.

 

Recovery/Value Billing

Another issue was the fact that it wasn't actually the new company that was the merchant services provider – the fact that they effectively outsourced that to the merchant services provider that gave the best deal.

That is the nature of recovery/value billing. The new company worked hard to secure a great deal and would continue to monitor it, regularly checking for the possibility of even greater savings.

In return, and as disclosed, they charged an ongoing fee for the value they provided. The deal they put in place was saving the merchant a significant amount of money on an ongoing basis, and they were billing a portion of that back in return. This merchant didn't like that.

 

It was a truly unfortunate situation with good people on both sides.



Tags: Pricing
Category: Selling

Related Content

Bad Design Creates Terrible Experience At Great Restaurant

Multiple paths to the same destination can seem user-friendly but, more often that not, it complicates decision making and necessitates more questions.

No, Flying Today Is Cheaper, Thanks To Unbundling

This article is fascinating because it so clearly misses the mark. Despite what the author says the cost of travel is cheaper today, thanks to unbundling.

Cost-Plus Pricing: It Can't Explain The Price Of E-Books

It's clear it costs less to distribute e-books than printed books, so why do e-books cost as much or more if price is determined by a cost-plus formula?

Lessons On Hurdles In Price Discrimination From The Airport

Airport car services use a well designed hurdle as part of a price discrimination strategy that limits discounts to only the most price sensitive buyers.

Florists and Restaurants: More in Common Than You Think

The flower business has much in common with the restaurant business (often more than with other retail) and florists can benefit from foodservice research.

Diminishing Marginal Utility

The underlying concept of diminishing marginal utility is easy to understand but the vagueness of the term makes the definition easy to forget.

First Beyond Cost Plus Sessions of 2015 Booked

New content on how florists can use advanced pricing strategies to increase the volume and profitability of their event business is coming to the GLFE and WUMFA Annual Conventions in 2015.

Thanks to the Florida State Florists' Association

It was a pleasure to attend and participate in the FSFA convention in Weston Florida and meet the amazing volunteers that put it all together. people that attended the session on how advanced pricing techniques can be used to increase sales and profitability in retail floral.

Beyond Cost Plus at the 2014 FSFA

I'll be presenting a Beyond Cost Plus session on new approaches to pricing and quoting events at the 2014 FSFA Annual Convention.

Same Product, Same Price, Different Expression & Results

A personal example of very different reactions to the same product at the same price but expressed using two different pricing models.

Category List


Tag List


Tag Cloud



Archive